I did not think much of this film after my first screening of it. Admittedly I watched rather quickly and did not take notes. Originally, I thought it to be a so-so piece. I did not think it broke many boundaries and I saw not much in the way of organization and motivation of shots.
I think what grabbed my attention the second time was when JFK was shaking the hands of his audience after a brief speech. The camera seemed to slip its attention ever so slightly to subjects other than the candidates. Emphasis began being placed more on the people being addressed. The camerawork adds, implicitly, a tone of importance onto the people, and lessens the significance of the actual speeches and politicians.
May 6, 2007
The War game today?
The Peter Watkins film The War Game which was originally made for BBC would not have the same effect today as it would when it was made. After networks telivised nearly all the action taking place in the gulph war, this country has been completely desensitized to images of war and violence. Not only the Gulph War , but images of the kids inside of Columbine High School, the footage of two planes flying into the world trade towers and a barrage of news footage everyday have shaped the way people view tthis type of footage. A film like The War Game would never fly these days. In it's time i'm sure it was shocking and contraversial, but nowadays it's watered down fiction. People are too burned out by images of human brutality that we actually expect to see it now; as disturbing as this may be it is the sad truth. And even more upsetting then that is the fact that it's only a matter of time befor someone does a terrible hollywood remake of The War Game and adds a ton of computer generated images and blood and gore. That's the only way people today would swallow it.
was resnais giving up on hiroshima mon amour a good thing?
So when resnais went into tackling hiroshima mon amour, he started out as making a documentary. This made sense at the time. night and fog was a big hit, and he was going to probably get a great response from the world again for making this hiroshima piece. Unfortunately he gave up on the idea of making documentaries all together and thus hiroshima mon amour becomes a narrative. This is troubling, because as anarrative, hiroshima mon amour was ironic and funny at points, but most of the time it was dull, unecessary and hard to follow. The shots in the film were well crafted, and there is something to be said about the way that resnais allows his cameras to pan at just the right moment, but this is present in all his pieces. The most interesting thing in the entire film was the first ten minutes of the movie. The way it was shot, the way it was edited, the way that it was intercut with the ashes falling on the naked bodies, all of these visually amazing elements made the first part of the film a beauty. I have seen few images in film that put me into such an involved trance. I couldn't pull my eyes away from the screen if I had wanted to. The rest of the movie had an interesting subject matter, and made me laugh occassionally, but as a whole the only thing that worked for me was the beginning of the film (the part that resnais made before he turned it into a narrative)
No lies... no holding back
The first time I saw No Lies I questioned whether it was real or not untill the credits rolled. After watching it again I still cannot believe how genuinly believable and powerful a film it is. Not the actresses performance, but the performance of the filmmaker was outstanding. The dialogue was very fluent and draws the audince in and makes for a very uncomfortable watch. The camera work especially hightens the realism with the amaturish zoom in/outs and the soft focus at times. No Lies still holds as much power today as it did when it was made.
Eyes on the Prize
This particular episode of the series dealt with The Black Panther Party and the riot at Attica prison. What struck me most were the layers of direct address and the differences between "then" and "now". In the archival footage from the past, people directly addressed their audience, not realizing that that film would be used years later for the documentary. In the "present day" interviews, the interviewees looked back on this footage and added new information to it, directly addressing their audience. One could say that the people speaking in the archival footage were both aware and unaware of their spectators. They knew they were speaking to people in their time, but, unbeknownst to them, a new breed of spectators would watch them again. The "present-day"interviewees gave a new voice to Fred Hampton and the Attica inmates, justifying their causes.
Punishment Park
Punishment Park worked on a very profound level. The film had a very real feel to it during the interogation scenes. The board of directors and the people being judged gave great very believable performances. The park scenes however, breaks the audience out of the realism of the film. For example, there waas a camera crew wwalking with the park prisoners and yet they seemed to have set shots of the prisoners walkingtoward them in the distance and set up shots that clearly took time to establish, yet the crew was on foot with the prisoners. Also, if the prisoners were on the run for their lives they would hardly have time to sit and discuss with the crew. The film as a whole works with the juxtaposing of dialogue in the courtroom and the images of the runners and provides a great look at the attitudes of the time.
Opening a Can of Youtube
Jeanne Hall opens her essay on cinema verite by talking about how on March of 1961 a can of worms was open and that can was cinema verite. The idea behind cinema verite is that it is pure life that is not interrupted by an agenda. While many will argue whether it will ever be 100% pure it is as close to uninterrupted life as one can get. For many years it has been strictly a documentary genre practice, but recently it has been taken over by the Internet. Anyone who has a camera and a computer will post their ideas feelings or whatever else they want on the Internet for all to see. I believe that this is the newest cinema verite movement. Yes, some of the stuff on the Internet is scripted and acted, but a lot of it is a thing that is just caught by the camera. Its anything from a kid opening a present and going crazy to outtakes of a man selling RV's swearing and cursing at his cameraman. Cinema verite will always be around within documentary but for this generation it has found its newest home on youtube and the Internet.
10 min.
What was Hiroshima like?
As an American it is never a topic that fills ones thoughts or
captures ones mind. They were the bad guys in the Great War
and that is that. In the film Hiroshima Mon Amour the idea
that Hiroshima actually happened to real people is brought
right to the front in the first ten minutes. The
French-speaking heroine of the film explains in a monotone
voice-over how she remembers Hiroshima, while her Japanese
counter-part explains to her that she does not.
Is Hiroshima a forgotten tragedy? Do people ever really think
about it happening? As the film slowly weaves inside and
outside of the museum dedicated to the catastrophe remembering
is forced into the viewers lap. The filmmaker is saying to
the viewer, "You will remember" even while the voice-over is
insisting that we don't. The archival footage is so raw and
real that it is impossible to look away even though the
rawness is the very reason to want to look away.
The weakness of the film is that it leaves this rawness and
enters into an over-dramatic fantasy level that is hard to
relate to. While the story of the film would normally be
somewhat compelling it cannot follow up the very real and
actual event of Hiroshima. The dramatic camera shots and
lighting can't compete with the real life footage of burn
victims and deformity of the bombing.
The realness of the first ten minutes pulls the viewer in with
incredible and brutal realism. The filmmaker saying, "Here it
is, do you remember?"
Punishment Park
I recall a friend telling me about this film within the last couple years - he had seen it somewhere and thought that the film was, in fact, "real". I remember thinking "Wow, that's incredible, I can't believe the kind of sh*t that happends in this country that you never hear about - it's unbelievable what our government can get away with". It's a relief to learn that this film is not, in fact, "real" - though there is so much in the film that feels authentic, and so much political turbulence in the contex/era in which it was made, I find it easy to stand behind my original reaction.
Watkins has a true gift for making comletely compelling, well-crafted, and important films out of seemingly little more than a moral imperative. Watkins is staunchly and unwaveringly ant-violence and anti-war and believeds it is his (and everyone's) responsiblity to promote world peace; for this film, he turned his eye to the U.S. While the fictional part of the film is "about" a federal tribunal that questions American radicals, rebels, and draft-dodgers and documents their choice to attempt to survive punishment park rather than serve a prison sentence, it functions on an allegorical level as well. Watkins cast non-actors in the film, choosing people with leftist values, political activists, "hippies" etc. to play the roles of "radicals" in the film, and chose people who were or had been police officers or were in the military or government to play the roles of officers and the federal tribunal. Some of the characters were based on members of the Chicago Seven, some of the non-improvised lines of the police officers were mimicking lines that various journalists had quoted from police officers in high-profile riots across the county, and the blatant abusive nature of the police in the film is reminiscent of actions of officers at the Kent State protests and in the 1968 democratic convention. Much of the dialogue and action were improvised - so people were largely "playing" themselves and the tension in the film was very real, and as good as any a gauge or record of the tension between, and among, these groups at the time - and even today. So, while the film serves as a specific allegory for the Nixon-era U.S. political climate and the atrocities of Vietnam, there is a larger allegory at work too. That is, abuse of power, the irrationality of violence, the plight of the political minority in the realm of an abusive and violent majority, the silencing and criminilization of dissent, and the struggle for true freedom - sound familiar, doesn't it?
Watkins has a true gift for making comletely compelling, well-crafted, and important films out of seemingly little more than a moral imperative. Watkins is staunchly and unwaveringly ant-violence and anti-war and believeds it is his (and everyone's) responsiblity to promote world peace; for this film, he turned his eye to the U.S. While the fictional part of the film is "about" a federal tribunal that questions American radicals, rebels, and draft-dodgers and documents their choice to attempt to survive punishment park rather than serve a prison sentence, it functions on an allegorical level as well. Watkins cast non-actors in the film, choosing people with leftist values, political activists, "hippies" etc. to play the roles of "radicals" in the film, and chose people who were or had been police officers or were in the military or government to play the roles of officers and the federal tribunal. Some of the characters were based on members of the Chicago Seven, some of the non-improvised lines of the police officers were mimicking lines that various journalists had quoted from police officers in high-profile riots across the county, and the blatant abusive nature of the police in the film is reminiscent of actions of officers at the Kent State protests and in the 1968 democratic convention. Much of the dialogue and action were improvised - so people were largely "playing" themselves and the tension in the film was very real, and as good as any a gauge or record of the tension between, and among, these groups at the time - and even today. So, while the film serves as a specific allegory for the Nixon-era U.S. political climate and the atrocities of Vietnam, there is a larger allegory at work too. That is, abuse of power, the irrationality of violence, the plight of the political minority in the realm of an abusive and violent majority, the silencing and criminilization of dissent, and the struggle for true freedom - sound familiar, doesn't it?
Hollywood>Almost anything.
After reading the George Custen writing on the biopic I am starting to see how Hollywood didn't just control how things shaped the society we live in today but still shape everything around our lives. I was walking through the airport yesterday and as I glanced up to the monitors in the terminal I found out that Paris Hilton was just sentenced to 45 days in jail for driving with a suspended license. Custen talks about how sketches of famous men and women were manufactured like commodities. And as I read that and see Paris on screen I see that Hollywood has not stopped creating products. Stars and celebrities are manufactured like commodities. The definition of a commodity is a raw material that can be bought and sold. It’s sad that Hollywood and the society that feeds of this information has turned people into an item to be bought and sold. I know that celebrities have accepted the spotlight but do we really need to know as much as we are told? It seems that we are in a position of authority to accept this obscured amount of information shoved in our face or to reject it. I hope that our society isn't defined by the personalities of the age but by the actions of people trying to change the hurt and suffering of the world. If we keep going to the direction we are and absorbing the media we do I think it’s going to be the former rather than the latter.
Grierson and Guffman
Within the interview sequences Guest uses the choice of location to continue to establish his characters through discontinuity. One of the three principles of documentary coined by John Grierson is that the original scene is a better guide to the interpretation of the world (Grierson 147). Christopher Guest uses this idea to develop the fragility and insecurities of his characters. By placing Libby Mae Brown in the sun at the Dairy Queen while wearing her uniform the filmmaker is subtly placing her into a stereotype. She is not interviewed at home but at the Dairy Queen because there is an established idea concerning people who work in fast food. In actual documentaries this is key to add a certain mood to the scene or the character. Guest uses this to his advantage to mark Libby as dumb and lower class. The original world makes for more interesting filmmaking and because this is the real world of her life it adds to the realism of Blaine, Missouri in Waiting for Guffman. Libby is not the only character cast with this light of stereotypes but all the characters; whether minor or major, have similar placement in their various locations. Dr. Pearl is not only placed at the dentist office to show that he is a dentist but to also show that this is his stage, where he thinks his comedy is most accepted. His subtle laughs and slight pauses show his insecurities within his world. He doesn’t just tell jokes and sit awkwardly in silence; he sits awkwardly in his own world, which adds to the discontinuity. Location adds to the discontinuity because the viewers of Waiting for Guffman are seeing the characters on their time and on their turf. In the same way Fredrick Wiseman documentaries bring viewers to the uncomfortable locations that he chooses to go, Christopher Guest brings viewers to the awkward world of Blaine, Missouri.
1+3=3.5
According to Ricky Leacock there are three approaches to cinema. The first is pure cinema that could be summed up as the tradition of Melies. The second is impure cinema that could be summed up in the tradition of Porter, and the third would be the realist and is summed up in the tradition of Lumiere. Basically there is fiction, art and documentary. I know that its not that simple or easily defined but even if we were to delve deep into each of the categories I believe that the films we have been studying this semester would be left out. It is too easy to just dump the films into either documentary or fiction and it doesn't make sense to dump them into art film. The course is defined as a documentaryfiction study course and that is exactly where these two films fit. They are documentary and they are fiction. They are both. They are one genre of genre blurring films that only create half an approach to cinema. While they don't fit into narrative fiction or documentary they do fit into both so the genre, while is a completely new approach has been done before, not fully, but still has. Overall I believe that while we can't give it a full credit as a new approach to cinema, we can give it half.
Bill Nichols/ The Fiction of Objectivity
In Nichol's article about realism and objectivity, he bring up the instance of the documentary maker. A filmmaker who decides to shoot a documentary separates himself from the activist in that while activists can pursue a cause on their own terms, filmmakers cannot. When making a documentary, one must represent more than one side in order to keep some notion of objectivity. Although a filmmaker can personally feel strongly about an issue, he can only construct his film in a way that suggests his stance, otherwise it becomes propaganda.
If you were to make a documentary, in order to keep objectivity the events must be reported as they happened historically. Any people or institutions involved must have their accounts of the events observed with skepticism. I personally feel that objectivity is a myth in film making. Objectivity is only possible when dealing with facts without commentary or outside representation. You can make a documentary about an apple on a table. It's true that the apple was on the table, but the camera will always suggest more than necessary. How is the apple shot? How is it framed? How close are we to it? What does it represent? How long do we see it? Who shot the film and why? Even though these questions may not have any relevancy to the film- or even the fact of the apple being on the table- the fact that they can and will eventually be raised strips the "documentary" of it's objectivity.
If you were to make a documentary, in order to keep objectivity the events must be reported as they happened historically. Any people or institutions involved must have their accounts of the events observed with skepticism. I personally feel that objectivity is a myth in film making. Objectivity is only possible when dealing with facts without commentary or outside representation. You can make a documentary about an apple on a table. It's true that the apple was on the table, but the camera will always suggest more than necessary. How is the apple shot? How is it framed? How close are we to it? What does it represent? How long do we see it? Who shot the film and why? Even though these questions may not have any relevancy to the film- or even the fact of the apple being on the table- the fact that they can and will eventually be raised strips the "documentary" of it's objectivity.
waiting for guffman
This film was definitely a refreshing watch in this class, it was nice to see a straight up comedy. I've seen this film before, as I'm sure most of us have - but in the context of a documentary fictions class, I thought about it differently. Previously, I had no experience wtih the larger scholarship or study of mockumentary, semi-documentary, or the fictitious nature of the documentary. I had, like much of our reading makes mention of, really taken documentary as "truth" or an attempt at the "most truth" and anything else as fiction and therefore fabricated or "not truth". So, looking at this comedy now, I see it differently. I'd never really noticed before how many conventions of documentary are present in this - the talking head interviews, the hand-held shots, etc., and found in prior views my suspension of disbelief and engagement with the film didn't allow me to see the moments when the film slips into a standard fiction film, those moments when the cameras are in places where they would not be - like Corky in the bathtub, or just outside his apartment, or fixed on a character in a crowd that will become the person we recognize as possibly guffman but isn't yet. The selectivity of the camera, the way the viewer counts on the camera to show us what is imporant and what we need to know is more a possiblity of fiction than a camera in the midst of an uncontrolled documentary would likely be. So, I really appreciated being able to notice more of these "lapses" between genres.
I think the thing that makes this film, and other Christopher Guest films so funny - is his attention to detail. Even though these characters are completely ridiculous, the amount of care, detail, and even subtlety applied to establishing their attributes gives the characters a realness that moves them beyond stereotypes. Guest seems to distill a "type" (folk musician, theatre director, dog owner..) down to a few particular elements and then amplifies those elements so that you only read that person as "travel agent" and then fills in bizarre quirks into that caricature that build incredible and strange, but also real-seeming personality back into the character. Ultimately, I think he has a great deal of appreciation for the characters he builds, I think he can probably relate to them on some level - the small town politics, the disappointment of failed dreams, bizarre theatre ephemera, I feel he really gets the details and uniqueness of various communities (theatre scene, hair metal bands, competitive dog show scene) from within it, not from the outside - and that's what makes the humor so successful. It's almost like an in-joke rather than a pointed joke. I'm sure his research process is fascinating.
I think the thing that makes this film, and other Christopher Guest films so funny - is his attention to detail. Even though these characters are completely ridiculous, the amount of care, detail, and even subtlety applied to establishing their attributes gives the characters a realness that moves them beyond stereotypes. Guest seems to distill a "type" (folk musician, theatre director, dog owner..) down to a few particular elements and then amplifies those elements so that you only read that person as "travel agent" and then fills in bizarre quirks into that caricature that build incredible and strange, but also real-seeming personality back into the character. Ultimately, I think he has a great deal of appreciation for the characters he builds, I think he can probably relate to them on some level - the small town politics, the disappointment of failed dreams, bizarre theatre ephemera, I feel he really gets the details and uniqueness of various communities (theatre scene, hair metal bands, competitive dog show scene) from within it, not from the outside - and that's what makes the humor so successful. It's almost like an in-joke rather than a pointed joke. I'm sure his research process is fascinating.
Steal Engines and Cardboard Rockets
Keil's article is about early cinema around 1905-06 period. At this point in history there was a transition going on in styles (non-continuitous to classical.) There was already a consciousness about the difference between fiction and non-fiction film. In fact early audiences had a preference for non-fiction. Fiction film often used a variety of material and combined staged and actual footage. Actuality footage could support the narrative or even become part of it. Eventually, as narrative film developed and matured, it took on a more invisible style and eclipsed non-fiction as the choice for film-goers.
Catherine Russell/ Surrealist Ethnography
For my final paper, I spent a lot of time looking at Las Hurdes and studying it. Catherine Russel's article on the film depicts it as a surrealist Ethnography. The film plays on our attraction to watching the Hurdanos suffer, rather than try to inform us about it, or make any changes to their situation. It does not try to build them as characters or even give us much information about them. Some of the information given by the narrator doesn't even match what we see on the screen. Bunuel's film feels like a mash-up of a bunch of different genres, especially the travelogue (which was the focus of my paper.) Some interesting references to the travelogue are the quick ordering of shots reminiscent of slide shows, which were the main visual format for lecture travelogues. Another reference is the blunt, condescending tone of the narrator. The narrator helps build discontinuity between sound and image, and the lack of sympathy in the descriptions borders on cruelty. This lack of sympathy both distorts our perception of the people in the film, and satirizes the travelogue lectures of the early 20th century.
Film for being a film
I have been waiting for an essay like Steve Neale's on Triumph of the Will. Neale brings up the fact that Triumph of the Will has never been looked at as a masterpiece of film. He does not ignore its emotional impact as well as its highly technical shooting. He explores how each shot emotes the core message of the film. For example, he comments on Hitler's evasiveness yet ever being present. Neale does not put down the film for its Nazism, which gives fair grounds for real interpretation. The purpose of the film is to build up Hitler and his power and the film does a great job. The message of the film overrides the direction in most dissections, but by doing that it ignores the mastery of the film.
Symbiopsychotaxiplasm
When this movie first started with several couples having the same argument, I was a little confused at what was going on, but I was completely enthralled with the absolute ridiculousness of the conversations, and the horrible acting by some of the couples. I kept asking myself "did people really used to say things like that to each other? do they still?" I was viewing the arguments as period pieces in and of themselves. As relieved as I was to get out of the montage of those couple arguments, when the film cut film cut to Michael Greaves and the camera crews I felt immediate disappointed, thinking I was in for a boring and sloppy "behind the scenes" of some film that I don't know or care about - and in effect, I was. However, the slight twist of "the behind the scenes of some film you don't know or care about IS the film" was enough to completey capture my attention again. The questions of how much did the director know or not know what he was doing or what would happen or what parts were real reactions and what were staged reactions are certainly interesting, but when I was watching it they didn't have too much bearing, for me, on the film. I was still fascinated with the completely outrageous "script" of the two characters and how their chemistry and behavior complete degenerated into what I would image is pretty unprofessional, but common. The guy living in the park was thoroughly entertaining and smart, he stands out in my mind as a really great "accident" in the film.
Oddly enough, in another class the very next morning a fellow student brought this film in to show in an exp. video class, and we watched about 20 minutes of it. He's doing a research thesis on this film, and accorting to him - Michael Greaves pretty much had the whole thing masterminded. He wanted to make a film of a film where the director drives both the crew and the actors to mutiny, and film it as the actual film - and it seems he succeeded. Apparently, the scenes we debated where the crew filmed themselves having a "behind the behind the scenes" discussion were also not scripted or directed. The crew was fed up and after a discussion in a bar one night, they decided to steal some film and start filming themselves talking about how screwed up the whole thing is, and after the "film" was through being shot, they gave the footage to Greaves as sort of a gift to say "you are a lousy director, here's our conversations about how lousy you are and how much this project sucks in the hopes that with some feedback you will not be such a lousy director in the future. Essentially they made a film within a film and played into Greaves more perfectly than he could have hoped for. All in all, I think this film is pretty much by filmakers for filmakers a degree to which I have never seen and probably never will see again - it's not surprising it was a flop and the time and is seeing a new life - particulary in a film department.
Oddly enough, in another class the very next morning a fellow student brought this film in to show in an exp. video class, and we watched about 20 minutes of it. He's doing a research thesis on this film, and accorting to him - Michael Greaves pretty much had the whole thing masterminded. He wanted to make a film of a film where the director drives both the crew and the actors to mutiny, and film it as the actual film - and it seems he succeeded. Apparently, the scenes we debated where the crew filmed themselves having a "behind the behind the scenes" discussion were also not scripted or directed. The crew was fed up and after a discussion in a bar one night, they decided to steal some film and start filming themselves talking about how screwed up the whole thing is, and after the "film" was through being shot, they gave the footage to Greaves as sort of a gift to say "you are a lousy director, here's our conversations about how lousy you are and how much this project sucks in the hopes that with some feedback you will not be such a lousy director in the future. Essentially they made a film within a film and played into Greaves more perfectly than he could have hoped for. All in all, I think this film is pretty much by filmakers for filmakers a degree to which I have never seen and probably never will see again - it's not surprising it was a flop and the time and is seeing a new life - particulary in a film department.
Punshiment Park
Punishment Park is Watkins' best film. Watkins is always trying to blur the line between reality and fiction by using the two interchangeably. Punishment Park is the perfect blend because he uses people who in real life hold the same position as their character. The action that follows from the court scenes feel real because the dialog was improvised. Improvised dialog which flows from the character is real for the scene. That gives an authentic feel for the moment because the words said fit. The only thing that was constructed was a basic plot outline. Larry David uses this technique in his show. David is a comedic Watkins. He directs Curb Your Enthusiasm based upon reality. The actors are all real friends of Larry David and play themselves with some changes. The storyline is outlined and the actors improvise the rest. Within the script, this is real action and reality for the scene. For me, improvised shows and films are captured reality.
Hiroshima
I found Hiroshima Mon Amour extremely hard to sit through. After a day or two afterwards I couldn't get it out of my mind. The levels within the film kept you thinking after the movie was over. What was it really about? Is it about the event, the relationship between the people, between the cultures, between the people and Hiroshima? I came to the conclusion that the film, in the end, spoke of relationship. The complexity of both characters is what drew the two characters together because they both relate to the world differently according to their histories. The reason the woman is so distressed is because of her relationship with the German. Her family didn't approve of relationshiop, neitheir did the family. The family's reaction was based on the daughter's relationship with the German. Though it's interesting to think about the film afterward, the hard part of watching the film is seeing their actions without knowing why they act in the way they do. Every action has a reason and a reaction, and that's what the movie tried to show.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)