May 7, 2007

THE Will.

Neale's article sees Triumph of the Will as as a means of Nazi propoganda. Beautifully done, masterfully put together, but none the less - plain propoganda. I can't argue with that- Triumph of the Will supposedly turned thousands of Germans towards the famed dictator Adolph Hitler to follow him into one of the most brutal wars the human race has known. It was put together specifically for that task - Hitler wanted to portray power, and show people that through his vision, he could share it with them. He knew very well Riefenstahl was capable of such a vision cinematically. After reading up on this, I discovered Riefenstahl, in fact, after being propositioned to do the film, turned him down: numerous times. But Hitler was determined, and would have no one else make the film. He promised to give her whatever he needed, and a budget wasn't necessary: he wanted this to be the biggest and best production possible in the name of the Nazi government. Every single part of it was staged - the perfect lines, the salutes, the car ride, the lines and lines of followers vying to see Hitler make his entrance. Camera posts were set up at all positions, not only on the ground, but on the outside of buildings and towers alike. Leni Rifenstahl nailed it - she not only gave him a visually bedazzling piece that raised him as nothing less than a god, but bridged the gap between some fancy uniforms and onscreen power. Afterwards she was hailed as an artist - and after the wars, accused of helping Hitler to wipe out millions. Was Riefenstahl responsible? After all, it was only her artistic vice in which aided Hitler in this film. People saw what they wanted to see - yes, she was able to convince them. She HAD to - shes an artist, a director, a true filmmaker. Holding her responsible would be holding any artist who has ever created something believeable responsible. To accuse her in aiding Hitler to wipe out millions is ridiculous, accusing her that she did a really, REALLY good job in helping people believe Hitler is "the man" - yup. Such is the life of an artist.

Mr. Bill Nichols

I really enjoyed reading Nichols view on fictional characters as compared to social actors, especially within a documentary. He thinks (his opinion) that people do not relate to fictional characters as they do with social actors. Thinking back in relation to many of the documentaries we've viewed in class, I never really wanted to see a fictional character anyway - I wanted someone with truth, and a problem, that we could follow and try to help them fix (or watch them fix, if you will). Nichols recognizes this, and states that because this person is true to life and relatable, though their purpose may or may not be ballooned up to be something much bigger than it really is, as an audience, we care, and will stay involved with their feat. Therefore, we are drawn to charcters that share relatable components and relate easier.






Bill Nichols’ brings up an interesting point of documentaries. Nichols says that people seem to pay less attention to fiction characters than to social actors. At first I did not agree with him. Look at the crazes of such films as Star Wars, Lord of the Rings and any Disney film. People love those characters and their story world. When watching a documentary you do tend to “prepare ourselves not to comprehend a story but to grasp an argument” (Nichols 5). The social actors are real so their status in the film is not only acting as a symbol for the greater society, but showcases an example from the story they are trying to highlight. Because the person is actual, no matter how the story is formed by the director, we care. Nichols brings up the point that because the character experiences similar “sounds and images…a distinct bond to the world we all share” (Nichols 5). So, though the documentary may be trying to expose a truth, the most important part that draws the viewer into the story is the fact that the story is true and all components are found in our own life. The more one can relate, the closer to the story one can feel.

Drama Doc. The Lowdown.

John Corner said "questions of reference concern how a particular programme [sic] relates itself to the real world, with what degree of specificity as to people, places, times, events and actions." (pg. 32) Usage of documentary elements in drama documentaries and fiction films are often used to engage the viewer and help an audience to relate to and understand a film. Many times, the footage used from any kind of documentary is more for a flashback through time and era - often political movies and film do this. It's never necessarily attractive, but highlights the necessary education elements. This often helps an audience to be taken back in to place in time, which better promotes the overall feeling of the film itself. In the end it is the creativity and path of the filmmaker that will be ultimate factor when it comes to the final composition. I think such cues allow greater control in the style of the film, as well as give a film (documentary or not) a more personal vice.




Dramatization in Documentary
In John Corner's article, Drama Documentary, he discusses the use of dramatization in documentaries and documentary elements in fiction films. The documentary elements of fiction films help to authenticate their main points and the dramatization in documentaries mostly help to engage the viewer. For the purposes of this essay, it will be discussed why dramatization in documentary is a necessity, but also how it can inhibit the main points of the documentary film.On the second column of page 32, Corner writes, "questions of reference concern how a particular programme [sic] relates itself to the real world, with what degree of specificity as to people, places, times, events and actions." In the case of the documentary, the authentic footage available is often un-cinematic. The point of the footage is not to be 'pretty' or engaging, but to highlight or simply display the factual elements. Because of this, it is often not the most interesting to view, at least not necessarily in large doses. Dramatizing scenes allows the filmmaker to create an aesthetic for appreciation by the audience and a visual cue for potentially uncaptured reported events. When the audience is allowed a visual memory of something, even if the footage is false, then the idea put across is taken as being more real, or factual. Film goers are also used to seeing cinema that is, well, cinematic. The stylistic elements of a film, i.e. choreographed shots, well placed edits, etc. are what draw the viewer into a fiction film and allow the movie to be viewed as it's own world, it's own reality, for the period of time during which the viewer is engaged. Using the same tricks in a documentary can capture an audience members attention and allow them to fall into that riveted and accepting state of being.However, the conventions of fiction film in documentary can also be distracting and take away from the reality of what is being viewed. When an audience member understands that the re-enactments are indeed full of tricky cinematic conventions, they may feel further distanced and become questioning about the validity in regards to the entirety of what is being viewed.There is no 'right way' to do it. There will always be a multitude of concerns when it comes to the creation of any film, documentary or otherwise. While potential issues should definitely be taken into consideration, in the end it is the mind of the filmmaker that will be the ultimate decision maker when it comes to the final composition. As personal opinion, I find that dramatized elements in a documentary give necessary visual cues and allow the filmmaker a greater control of the stylistic feel of the film, also giving the documentary a personal voice that high lights the reality of the impossibility of personal objectivity.

Symbiopsychotaxiplasm - Oh. Geez.

William Greaves attempted to create a "new" kind of film. "New". Whatever that means. This is never going to be one of those films I go back and watch again because I feel I've "missed something". In fact, the entire hour and a half of it I had NO idea what I was watching. I saw people acting, people trying act, people acting trying to act like they weren't acting (?), a director that had no idea what the heck he was doing, no drive, and a crew that was just as clueless as me (that part, I liked. Their conversations were the one breath of fresh air that "film" had). After reading some of the other blogs related to this, I saw that many people saw it as one of those films that makes you guess it it's legit or not, whether the actors were in fact acting horribly on purpose or because they were just plain bad,

Fake or Not to Fake? - Pseudodocumentary (Chap. 3)

I've always liked the word "psuedo". Never really knew what it meant, always assumed it was similar to a version of something. Thus. Psuedo-documentary. = "like" a documentary. Then there's the fact that there are loads of definitions for drama documentaries. Genre conventions have no weight, other than camera movement and technique. It's interesting to hear it described in this way. Honestly, before coming to this class, I had no idea how blurry the lines were between a documentary and a non-documentary in general (aside from camera shots, etc). But then comes the different segments of a documentary, which blurrs lines even more. Chapter 3 brought me t oa conclusion that documentary is something that will forever keep changing to meet the needs of not only the director but the audience, and classification of a documentary film is more or less based on opinion than book savvy fact.

House on 92nd St. Propoganda?

Do we really think that house on 92nd St was indeed propoganda? That wasn't quite the first thing that came to mind while watching it - I loved what the movie was - a war noir that got your heart rate going. Extremely entertaining, and believeable. But why must we jump to the face that it was meant to be propoganda? Why can't it just be what it IS: entertainment for an audience that was in the middle of a war? I suppose you could look deeply into it, examine it's makeup and probably come to the conclusion that the government is indeed trying to relay its deep dark secrets. I definitly saw the message that the FBI is meant to be feared and that they mean business. It closed in the idea that no one can ever get away with anything under the clear and precise watch of the ever so sneaky FBI - I can see how this made people feel safe, probably at a time when their government wasn't telling them much to begin with. The stereotypical masculine woman came to be very interesting to me - I never really thought anything of it until after the movie.

Guffman was worth the wait

Waithing for Guffman was fantastic, and I couldn't have picked a better film to have been shown to emphasize documentary in the modern day comedy. I love Christopher Guest's in depth portrayl of his characters, and how each of them fed off of the town and one and other. I felt like I was watching a circus the entire time - some of it was just so ridiculous, but, in fact, did remind me of everyday people in everyday situations. Who doesn't want to get out of their small town and make something of theirselves? Recapture their youth? Find some sort of path to take before you end up working drive through of a fast food place the rest of your life? In the quest to figure out who they were and where they wanted to go, watching the caust of Waiting for Guffman literally made my day and left me wondering how I had never come across this film until this class.

Hiroshima, Mon Amour

Easy to watch? Eh, sometimes. It's catchy, and was way ahead of it's time. Easy to understand? No - no, not really, you have to work with it and follow it through. BUT, once you to follow where it's going, Hiroshima, Mon Amour, a really beautiful peice of poetry transferred to the big screen. Renais was truely talented, and had an incredible understanding of human emotion and reaction. It would have been difficult for any director to portray such a complex story in a way that an audience could view and understand, but Renais was able to take the story and make not only a film, but a peice of art. The film was almost like picture poetry - I don't think I'd ever seen anything like it, apart from more art oriented films full of music and singing about your emotions as to make them perfectly clear (Moulin Rouge, Chicago, etc)
I think the thing I enjoyed most about this film was its connections - to each action there was a reaction, to every reaction a reason. Not only was it a love story between Lui and Elle, but a relationship between Nevers and Hiroshima. Both stories seemed to run parrallel to one and other. Nevers basqued in sun the day Hiroshima was bombed - years later, as Hiroshima heals, Nevers is left guilty and can't seem to move on from the tradgedy. As she tried to make peace with Hiroshima, she finds it isn't, in fact, Hiroshima that she needs forgiveness from - it's herself.
Resnais took a documentary appeal mixed with a VERY modern approach to filmmaking in Hiroshima, Mon Amour, and it worked beautifully.

Goodnight & Goodluck - Kudos, Clooney

I never had much interest in seeing this movie while in theaters. Nothing against it right off the bat, just wasn't my cup of tea. I'm really glad I didn't, because I don't think I would have had the opportunity to enjoy it the way I did. I really liked looking at Good Night and Good Luck from the angle we were able to - as a makeshift documentary. Clooney did fantastic - from the props to the archival footage, I think it all came together really well and looked great. I hate it when people think you can make a movie in black and white and all of a sudden it will we a 1950's noir looking classic - it's so much more than that. The movie itself did well with connection human traits to the media boom and the growing world around them, and did a really, really great job of using documentary style shooting to bring a legitimate piece of time and a really memorable story to the big screen in a fashion that modern day audiences could enjoy.

Realism as a Style in Cinema Verite: Technology and Primar

The role of technology in Primary is integral to the execution of the ideals of Drew, and cinema verite (a label he did not choose, or enjoy). Drew wanted to “be there when the news happens”, was “determined to be as unobtrusive as possible”, and was “determined not to distort the situation”. In order for Drew to act as near as possible to a fly on the wall, the technology had to evolve to allow cameras and sound recorders to fit into the space of a car, to record audio, to edit on the road. Drew helped to engineering equipment that was capable of doing this, and set out on the road in Primary. At one point Leacock and Drew drop midgetape records into ashtrays around Kennedy’s hotel room and Leacock sat down and casually held the camera in his lap an filmed Kennedy claiming, “I’m quiet sure he hadn’t the foggiest notion I was shooting” and this, apparently, moments like this make Leacock and Drew believe they are accomplishing their goal, biut how can they, or anyone know what was really happening. Perhaps Kennedy decided to assume that the cameras are always recording and to act accordingly at all times.
Despite technology, despite the tiny microphones and smaller cameras, it’s still impossible for the crew to disappear, that their choices of framing a shot, editing a shot, and the very presence of the camera impacts behavior or the subject and therefore can never truly capture “reality” as it unfolds. This is why, according to many theorists in Hall’s article – Drew Associates and other practitioners of cinema varite come off as naïve and foolish, caught between arguments that “the truth no longer lies in seeming to give a good performance but in seizing the individual unawares[. . .].” (Marcorelles, 1963) and “given that no film can ever break down completely the barrier between the real world and the screen world, cinema verite knowingly reaches for unattainable goals” (Mamber, 1974) and “this claim to a new privileged grasp of reality appears in retrospect to have been somewhat naïve” (Waugh, 1975). Essentially, the mood shifted from the belief in the possibility of filming something unmitigated to the realization that it is impossible to do so. Introducing the idea of reflexivity – the act of the filmmaker visibly and intentionally injecting themselves, their presence, and the camera into the frame in an obvious manner was an attempt at again trying to capture this notion of “reality” and an “honest” documentary – but if we take Michael Moore, for example, I can’t make any claims that his documentaries are any more honest and real than those that are not reflexive.
I think the closest comparison I can think of for reaching some of the goals that the critics and theorists in Hall’s essay articulate again involves technology. Reaching actual unmitigated actuality footage seems more possible in the realm of surveillance video, not so much that in the realm of House on 92nd street, but more the footage that would come from a security camera, a camera in a store, on a traffic light, in center city, on temple campus. Here, the camera is in place, constantly surveying the action around it, without the touch of the hand to select what is important – there is no music, no narrator, no editing. Whatever happens, happens. Of course, the verite aspect can be breached again if the subjects are aware the they are on surveillance cameras, in fact, this is some of the point of surveillance. Though, perhaps we are so used to surveillance that 1)our behavior is constantly monitored such that it produces a new normative behavior or 2) we don’t care any more and behave as we would without the presence of the camera. This type of footage, gathered as far from human intervention as possible, may approach the goals of verite.
Another aspect of technology that may alter the possibilities, and realities of verite is videoblogging in the style of personal narratives. Access to a camera, editing equipment, and a means of distribution (internet) is fairly common and in these circumstances, the subject can tape themselves, edit themselves, appear reflexively as well as subjectively in the video. One could, at any moment, click on video that is a self-made interpretation of reality – there is often little explanation, no voice-over narrator, no context, and little knowledge about how why or where the video was made. It could easily be a subjects deliberately “constructed” representation of reality – but even that process is, in and of itself, an unmigited true reality. It’s not a perfect theory, but neither are the theories in Hall’s article – they are all attempts at solving the riddle of reality and representation but after reading her essay and all the contrasting arguments, I found myself wondering if it “really” matters.

Real Emotional Logic: House on 92nd street

Lipkin argues that docu-dramas, in order to work, rely on an almost unspoken agreement between the film maker and the audience – a suspension of disbelieve whereby the audience accepts at the very premise of the film, and at face value, that the blending of these two genres is in fact the best, if not the only way that the subject matter can be presented. This is particularly evident in TCF post World War II docudramas; House on 92nd street comes to mind. At the beginning of the film, the cast credits are the first thing the viewer sees, printed on FBI logo paperstock with “Federal Bureau of Investigations” official cover sheet and the words “Twentieth Century Fox Presents” imposed over it (as part of the titling of the film). From the very outset, the viewer is situated somewhere between the two planes of documentary (the FBI paperstock) and a dramatization (the Twentieth Century Fox logo). Inside this FBI file are the cast,credits, and a message to the viewer that the story is adapted from espionge cases from the files of the FBI, and was made with their complete co-operation. The text says “It[the film] could not be made public until the fist atomic bomb was dropped on Japan.” Right away we see the justification that Lipkin predicts. Lipkin says “re-creation and fictionalization are warranted – justified – to the extent that the resulting docudrama indicates its connections to actuality”. Lipkin goes on to discuss that Zanuck, the studio head at TCF, was among the first studio heads to take his crews on location and this information, is in fact, next to appear in our FBI file of movie credits and info. We learn that the picture was filmed on location when possible in the “actual place the original incident occurred”. Upon close inspection of the film and the information we have been give so far, we learn that this story (fiction, mind you) was based on a series of various cases from FBI files – yet here we are told that there is an original incident, singular, that is about to be illustrated. Already we have made a subtle suspension of disbelief, and we are only one and a half minutes into the film. Just in case we are still skeptical, however, the next information we are given is that all F.B.I personnel in the picture are actual members of the FBI. If we weren’t ready to make that leap of faith moments ago, we likely are now.
Lipkin states that many of these docu-dramas were categorized as film noir, but also as social problem films. TCF, due to it’s frequency of the production of these films were making a “strategic effort to exploit actuality” because, Lipkin argues, the market demanded it. These films did extremely well at the box office, were widely praised by critics, and really seemed to speak directly to the needs of a post WWII America – perhaps something about the mix of fiction and reality; the conventions of fiction filmmaking that prescribe a tidy narrative and formal closure mixed with the authenticity and centering voice of moral authority, command, control, and assurance common in documentaries all solidified by deliberate studio choices - such the formal choice of casting b-list actors who were familiar but could also be anybody - was a safe and effective way for Americans to recover from some of the trauma and social issues that WWII brought to light. These TCF fox films were probably just the right timely balance of reality to make them seem relatable, relevant, and credible, mixed with a fiction that allowed the viewer to “get lost” in the film and then feel a sense of resolution and resulting security that was probably missing from their lives.

Symbiopsychotaxiplasm - Take One

In this film, the blurring of the lines between documentary and fiction is very apparent. Even though it is very loose in its construction, which can be related to the documentary style, it does have narrative qualities beneath the surface. The film tells the tale of the main character, a film director named William Greaves, who attempts to create a different kind of film. Whether he is successful or not is up to the viewer after the film has ended. It is also possible that the film as a whole is purely fiction, and none of what appears to be spontaneity is actually real. There are several moments in the film, most coming from the conversations with just the crew, where the viewer second guesses what they are watching, as some of the subjects within the film support the idea that they are just carrying out the director's plans. Even the actors taking part in the film within the film could be portraying themselves as horrible performers to enhance other parts of the film to make it seem more "real". The homeless man at the end, for example, could have been an actor playing that part. These are the questions that get raised anytime a filmmaker tries to mix fiction elements with documentary form.

The House on 92nd Street

This is an interesting film to examine because it takes its form less from documentary and still has a very propaganda-like nature to it. Perhaps it could be labeled a propaganda-narrative for the sake of this criticism. The overall message of the film is that the Federal Bureau of Investigation is the smartest law enforcement organization on the planet. In case the viewer had any question about this, they only need to watch the closing of the film where the shield of the FBI takes up the whole frame.

The way that the Germans are portrayed in the film is very similar to what one would expect from a propaganda film. The stereotype of the females being masculine in nature, for example, and the chance at every turn to show that the enemy cannot get away with anything under the watchful eye of the FBI; these work to make the viewer feel confident that the U.S. Government can prevail in the face of any danger, even the possibility of the Germans procuring the most dangerous weapon in the world.

Gomez on Culloden

ONce again this is pretty good analysis of a watkins work. It gives the background and the post production and product feeling of the director with regards to his piece. Gomez does well at showing the difference in the honest (or sincereity) of watkins fictional work versus the dishonesty of something that is claiming to be entirely real. This is the difference between someone like watkins versus say ken burns. Not that Ken burns isn't willing to tell the truth, but Ken Burns is never going to be willing to delve into the psyche as much as watkins would. Furhtermore burns works solely in a factual form that is based on written acounts, and documented testimonies, but Burns always comes off as detached, and not really apealing to be honest. Anyone can tell a story in a monotone voice, and bore everyone in the room. Watkins' stories may not be real, but he keeps the viewer riveted, and he make them care about the situation that occurred, and the people harmed by it. Burns tried to show america the civil war, and he put most of america to sleep. Culloden raised anger, disgust, and hate in its viewers. It's a shame that he was so disappointed with the final result.

Reality TV: Poisioning America

Reality TV has become a pain here in America and it is ruining the younger generation. Reality TV claims to be real when in fact it is coherced in every way. Producers play a big part in this process. They are the ones responsible for making a reality show worth watching. How does this happen? Well situations are setup by them. They make sure there is some form of controversy that will take place to give the show an entertainment value that will keep the viewer drawn to it. Reality shows are not scripted line for line, but they are scripted in the sense that the producers are going to know exactly what is going to happen each day. So there is not much reality behind the concept if scenes are being forced to happen and just do not happen naturally. Look at Jerry Springer for example. The guests are real and the situations are real, but the producers coherce them in to acting like animas when they are on their show for the sake of being exciting and keeping the viewer drawn to the show. Tis reality tv boom has lead to a nonstop exploitation of everything. From the Amish people to babysitters everyone is getting on the reality tv boom. Youtube is a result because of this phonomenom and this is where the younger generation is getting the wrong impression. They are jumping on this bandwagon not knowing the demeaning values that it has in the end.

Gomez on watkins

Gomez does a pretty good job of going through giving the reader an idea of how this film came to be. Like most great films, this one was not intended to be made, or should I say was not some weird amazing Idea that watkins came up with all on his own. It came to watkins through a series of events, let downs, a circumstances, and then finally was made. If one watches the director interview with watkins on the dvd to punishment park, they will see and hear watkins talk about alot of the stuff mentioned in the gomez article. It's interesting that three films losing funding, and a dis heartened watkins being touched by the events that surrounded the kent state massacre, would eventually lead to what I feel is one of deepest and most profound mockumentaires ever made. Gomez does a good analysis of this film and how it came to be.

Reality Tv

Audiences are addicted to reality tv because of the allusion of truth. In chapter 7 of Faking It, reality tv is used as an example of a category 2 mockumentary. Roscoe and Hight write reality tv shows need to have a sense of ethical morality. Included in reality tv are shows like ER. CSI would fit into this as well. Look at the cultural impact of CSI. Before the show, science was not cool and there weren’t kids coming out of high school dreaming of being a crime scene investigator. Because dramatic cases occurred within a non-fiction setting of an occupation, the events seem like simulated life. But this is not the case, life is not as exciting and exotic as it appears on tv. To go more mainstream reality tv, shows like Real Life promote a certain type of reality. Producers construct a house in which drama will likely happen. Cameras are situated all over the house waiting to capture a moment that can be used in the editing room. Most events are not planned but the way they are edited take the action out of context and leave the viewer to believe other wise. Reality tv will always be an oxymoron for shows previously mentioned. Shows, for example seen on Animal Plant, are better examples of how a reality tv show should be structured. The camera is used for interesting angles but keeps out of the false construction and is addressed by the hosts. The acknowledgement from the host to the camera makes a trust bond between the host and the viewer. Anything as melodramatic as Real World is not reality, it’s just a night time parody of soap operas.

The Degree 3 Documentary

In Faking it, Roscoe and Hight break documentaries up into three levels. The first level is a simple parody that only reflects on the subject while using a documentary structure. The second level is documentaries having a subtle look upon themselves while they have constructed a parody. The most complex level is a parody on the structure itself. In the book they mention Man Bites Dog, but I think Medium Cool could fit into this category as well. As in Man Bites Dog, Medium Cool, plays with the media roles of the character. At the end, the characters die and the camera focuses on the lens of the camera, a comment about the whole structure of not just this film, but of the film community. People of all backgrounds can enjoy the category 3, but it would be the most interesting to people within the film community. The more one knows about a situation, topic, structure ect. The more one can take out of mockumentary.

Identification through realism and fiction

Fiction and truth are separate ideas but always work in some type of ratio. Without truth, fiction is unattainable, and without fiction, or a constructed narration, truth can be horribly boring and drawn out. Films that take place during a specific time use the time for a prop. The time era helps narrate a story, it does not keep the message time specific. Nichols uses American Graffiti as an example. Yes, the film does comment on the restlessness of teens during the 1950s, not much has changed within human nature today. Errol Morris does a good job at mixing truth and fiction. All his stories are true but keeps the viewers engaged by placing truth in a fiction format. Also, Nichols mentions Triumph of the Will, as an example of fiction in truth. Because the editing is used to enforce and idea and not continuity it is an example of distorted truth; fiction. We watch these films because the use of fiction brings us in and entertains us while pointing out the heart of the film.

Trust

Bill Nichols’ brings up an interesting point of documentaries. Nichols says that people seem to pay less attention to fiction characters than to social actors. At first I did not agree with him. Look at the crazes of such films as Star Wars, Lord of the Rings and any Disney film. People love those characters and their story world. When watching a documentary you do tend to “prepare ourselves not to comprehend a story but to grasp an argument” (Nichols 5). The social actors are real so their status in the film is not only acting as a symbol for the greater society, but showcases an example from the story they are trying to highlight. Because the person is actual, no matter how the story is formed by the director, we care. Nichols brings up the point that because the character experiences similar “sounds and images…a distinct bond to the world we all share” (Nichols 5). So, though the documentary may be trying to expose a truth, the most important part that draws the viewer into the story is the fact that the story is true and all components are found in our own life. The more one can relate, the closer to the story one can feel.