May 7, 2007

Good Night and Good Luck

Here's a film that caught my attention early on, and I'm happy it has received the credit it deserves. The storyline alone is compelling, showing a newsmedia team battling against the societal norm in broadcasting. The acting definitely makes the piece work very well, but the mise-en-scene really transforms the audience into the era. Black and White is used effectively, and with sharp contrast. Lighting plays a critical role, both in the studio and elsewhere to accentuate subtleties and create a visually interesting set. And back to the storyline; scripts that are based on history are tricky, as they must live up to that time. Good Night and Good Luck does good on that, representing a news reporters' drive to relay the facts to the American People.

The Battle of San Pietro / December 7th

The difference between the films The Battle of San Pietro & December 7th is great, even though at their core, they are both propaganda films coming out of World War II. In San Pietro, the American involvement in the war is legitimized, and there is sympathetic imagery of the poor villagers, mainly children, who have reason to rejoice because the U.S. has come and saved the day. Although obvious, the messages of the film work on a much more subtle level than December 7th, which leaves the viewer feeling like they have been beaten with a star-spangled baseball bat. From the over-the-top narration, to the cartoon-like stereotypes of the Japanese, to the thoughts of the dead at the end, it's surprising that there was not an advertisement to buy war bonds somewhere during the credits. Both films try to stir the patriotic feelings within all Americans, and it seems that The Battle for San Pietro was probably more effective on audiences, because December 7th is just too heavy-handed, at least by today's standards.

Phony Definitions

This chapter is a little confusing at first, but makes sense when trying figure it out. The author talks about how the fake world reflects the real world. Typically when something fake it being portrayed in film, it was thought up because of something real. The book uses the example in Citizen Kane. The newsreel is what they say is the fake reflecting the real because it represents who owns the media, whos is in the news, and what it is about. Even though the character is fake, The news is handled in that same manner. What the chapter is highlighting is that fake documentaries, ven though labeled fake, have a certain reality behind their structure. They undoand then redo reality and just put a twist on it. That goes for most "real" documentaries because one can argue that the same process takes place. A direcor will always have their own spin to put on it. Fake docs also do not suggest the truth of the real documentary. That becomes noticeable through the rather obvious flawed depiction of their subjects. It will also not fall back upon the authorizing function of its form. Though it gets its label of fake, it is using the real as its foundation leaving the viewer the question the authenticity of the real documentary.

steve neale, triumph of the will

Whether or not he got paid to make this article as boring as it was, or maybe neale is just a dull guy, but either way this article could put peaople on speed to sleep. Who cares if neale does a break down of every single shot in the first few minutes of the film. That is the difference between still photography and the moving image, you can't dissect it like you could stills. One is not going to figure out why Triumph of the will is considered a great movie based on Neale exlpaining every shot. The viewer will only understand the movie, and how it was able to affect a country by watching it. Picassos work can be explained. Shakespear can be read. But neither one of these works are worth anything unless you see them in person live. Not to say that any good art should never be talked about, but the director of Triumph of the will took care of the shot by shot pre production aspect of the movie, just show me the movie.

The television genre book

This was another article that seemed very hung up on the idea of labels and making sure that everything that was made had place where it could be categorized. When one breaks it down, there could be hundreds of different ways to categorize films, and to get stuck on these sepereate ideas of what constitutes what can be called apseudo documentary vs. a portrayal or mockumentary, it's all just ways for people to try to sound smart. The "drama documentary" the day after could be considered just that. But it also could simply be considered a drama. Or better yet, a made for tv drama. Or someone might just call it a movie, or amade for tv movie. Yes, it takes real ideas, and places characters in scenarios that could actually happen, but it is also a fictional film that has no relvance to anything that has happened, nor is it trying to appear that way. So pretty much anything that any viewer wanted to call it would work. The day after seemed most like an action movie to me, if anything.

Bill Nicoles: Modes of Representation

Bill Nicoles really gives a detailed explanation on the history of documentary film. The four different modes that he covers was the expository, observational, interactive, and reflexive. He explained that expository was the first of the modes. I had a demeaning quality behind it because it basically had a way of telling the viewer what to think. This lead to the observational documentary. Since synchronous recording equipment was more readily available and there was a dissatifaction with the moralizing commentary of the expository documentary, filmmakers thought this would be a new wave in documentary filmmaking. Observational documentary limited the filmmaker to the movement, required deetachment from the event themselves, but also relied on the filmmaker to be unobtrusive. That is where this mode, how perfect it may seem, stills falls short of being demeaning. Though there is no voice over, the editing is what is relied upon to enhance and manipulate the impression of lived or real time. Though it is what started the Cinema Verite movement, it became just another mode of documentary failing to ignite the movement it was once anticipated to. The interactive mode is what had come next and involved using an interviewer to talk with the subjects and then of the the reflexive mode which was the last of the modes Bill Noicoles describes.

Jonathan Rosenbaum

It seems like This guy was just getting a little too defensive, and wanted to make sure that some of his favorite movies got taken seriously. Somethings are dubbed somethingbecause that's the easiest way to describe them. Whether one wants to call it a pseudo documentary, a re enactment, or an emulation or imitation of something that once occured, it is going to called a mockumnetary (especially by people outside of the extremely intelligent film theory circle). Rosenbaum was primarily criticising scholars for using the term, but they have every right. Part of the reason that mockumentary stuck is because some of the most successful fake documentaries were these funny films that were dubbed mockumnetaries. Punishment park is by no means a funny movie, if anything it is more of hypothetical re enactment of what happens who countires turn into fascist states. BUt that is a long winded description, and the truth of the matter is someone could just as easily say its a dark mockumentary. Unfortunately this a debate that has the natuarl progression of a circle, but Rosenbaum (not yet at least) to be quoting wikipedia in a scholarly paper/article

Hail Primary

Jeanne Lynn Hall's, “Realism as a Style in Cinema Verite: A Critical Analysis of Primary" was a waste of time. Perhaps if I was entirely unfamilar with the way that films were made, this article would have been useful to me, but after more thanf our years of film school, it was mainly just a waste of time. I understand that she was trying to break down the film in what was almost a shot by shot analysis of the events that occurred, but why? Was article for people who were not film majors? Even though primary itself was a ground breaking film and something that many had not seen, the craft of making films was around for almost seventy years when primary first came out. People in the movie business understood what was involved with making Primary, and all the techniques that Drew was using to subtley get his message across. Plus, if the article is not for people in the business and directly involved in film, then who was Hall trying to reach. It just seems that if one is writing an article for a group of people that study film, or dissect films, or converse about films on an intellectual level, she should do more than simply break down techniques to make two things look like they are related.

Leacock uncontrolled cinema

Leacock is truly a ground breaking guy. Pennebaker and Drew did a lot for film, a direct cinema in particular, but Leacock really had his mind straight when it came to what makes good film making. He took some new approaches to the craft of film making, and also was willing to accept that part of what he was doing was journalism, and thus he always had that in mind when making his documentaries. What always strikes me as interesting, is that you can Leacock's school of though which is get out of the way and let the action happen. Or you can have someone like jean rouche who not only will direcet the action in his "documentaries" but he will also have his subjects do multiple takes of real life playikng out before the camera. Personally I like leacock pictures more than Jean rouche films, but both Directors approaches are so different, and the things that Leacock complains about in the uncontrolled cinema article have a lot to do with how well he can make a piece, because in Leacock's eyes being a fly on the wall is the only way to truly tell what happenes. Jean Rouche is so involved anways in creating reality that he robably didn't have as many problems with the old style of shooting sync sound as Leacock did.

No Lies

After viewing Mitchell Block’s No Lies, one cannot help but think of the ethics involved in documentary filmmaking. Block himself must have had a fairly good understanding of these ethics because he did something to his film that took it from a film that was an invasion of the poor girl’s privacy to something less unscrupulous. He added credits to let the viewer know that the film was fiction. In doing this, the viewer can feel a little jilted if they had sympathy for the rape victim in the story, but they end up feeling relieved that it didn’t really happen to her. What would have been the reaction if there was no writing or directing credit at the end, and it was presented as a true documentary? It seems that the film may have gained more attention, because the controversy involved would have certainly opened more eyes. After that, Block would have to come clean, then be burned at the stake. His credibility as a filmmaker would be lost and he would probably have a hard time finding a job. Perhaps he knew all of this ahead of time and decided to head it off at the pass and just put those credits in the end. It ends up being a subtle shock, but not the public outrage it could have been.

Documentary Style in Citizen Kane

After the opening scene in which Charles Foster Kane utters his final word and passes away, the film transitions to the “News on the March” newsreel. The choice to incorporate the documentary style into Citizen Kane was most likely because Welles felt it was the best way to create the illusion that this man was real. Handheld shots were utilized and supposedly some of the negatives were run across the editing room floor to add scratches and dust to make it appear like it has been projected so many times. Combined with the “voice of god” narration, this segment of the film attempts to show the viewer the true story of the character’s successes and failures in life. It also sets up an objective view of who Kane was, and these facts will either be supported or contradicted as the film goes on and the reporter interviews those close to Kane.

When Orson Welles conceptualized the “News on the March” segment, he was just continuing what he started with his War of the Worlds radio broadcast, which was trying to convince the audience into believing something is real, making the film more enjoyable.

Drama/Documentary

Exploring the differences and similarities of documentaries that utilize dramatized parts (reenactments, primarily) versus dramas that utilize documentary-style research/footage, the author suggests that there is a need to distinguish them from one another for audience understanding and clarity. The audience needs to know if what they are watching is "real" or "fake" and can have reactions other than what the filmaker intended if they are not give this information upfront (No Lies).
Movies are powerful, and can have the power to re-energize or even re-write popular versions of history (as Linda Williams writes in “Mirrors Without Memories”). If that is true (and I do agree with her) then the question of historical authenticity or of disclosure from the filmmakers becomes quite interesting.
Responsibility and accountability in filmmaking (and in any art in general, really) are constant yet shifting issues. As a maker of art, should you contextualize your work for your audience? (maybe…) As a consumer/critic of art, should you consider its production and historical accuracy? (probably…) I think that the responsibility for making connections beyond the work out into the rest of the world (art world, film world, or whole world) is up to the viewer/consumer, and not the artist. As a maker of media, you should be aware of your context, histories and genres and try to anticipate and understand the implications of your work. What you choose to do about these things is clearly a more personal, singular decision, but reflexive awareness adds clarity, and the ability to discuss and define those choices can only aid in your own understanding of your work.
Having said that, I think that the audience also has a responsibility to be active, and more active than we are typically are asked to be in our consumption of films, art etc., If we are accountable to ourselves and to each other, and discuss the film/art, there is the possibility of understanding something broader or more applicable, its ramifications in our lives, or seeing something in a new way. Through dialogue, any authenticity, history, or lack thereof can be challenged, allowing another story/reality to emerge.

Stiry/Discourse

Story/Discourse
A Note On Two Kinds Of Voyeurism

The author describes a balance of physical absence and presence in the cinema: when the actors are acting, the audience is not there, and when the audience is watching, the actors are gone, leaving their performances captured on film. They position this relationship as typical of cinema, and parallel it with the historical rise in the importance of the private individual vs. the community, by suggesting that the spectator doesn’t need to be seen while watching nor does the person being watched need to see the “see-er”. Both understand their specific roles, though there is not an activity that is shared between them, and a dialogue or interaction is impossible.
I think that this distancing of the subject (active, watcher) from the object (passive, actor) in this equation facilitates some of the “magic” of movies. It, along with the specific characteristics of film as a medium, allows the construction of a more “believable” world, a faraway fantasy world, where the viewer can see the actor and watch their every (calculated, edited, scripted) move with no real physical consequence, though they still engage emotionally with the story. Different from plays or live musical performances, movies can allow for a closer-than-normal/hyper real understanding of a situation or story, by specifying a frame for the viewer. Using cinematography, musical scores, sound editing, and special effects, movies have a one-way communication out of the screen and into the eyes/ears of the audience. The actors never hear the clapping at the end of the screening (which I always think is an odd thing to witness and points to a sort of collective audience experience) – and yet they never fail to be motivated to perform.

Documentary Contradictions

In Paul Arthur’s “Jargons of Authenticity (Three American Moments”, he quotes Brian Winston who says, about documentary film, that “ ‘the need for structure implicitly contradicts the notion of unstructured reality’ and documentary movements are sustained by ‘ignoring this contradiction’”.

Don’t we ignore this contradiction in all movies? Do we want the same things from documentaries as we want from fictional films: sympathetic characters, compelling crisis, understandable and complete resolution? Because documentaries are based in “reality”, we expect a portrayal that is unencumbered by cinematic/narrative structures. The impossibility of this all-seeing camera or unbiased portrayal is suggested by Winston, and has easy proofs. It seems we crave, or are trained, or almost expect fictional devices anyway – we will put the pieces together and construct a narrative whether we are given one or not.

Popular, contemporary documentaries like Spellbound or Rock School show “real people” in “real” but somewhat extraordinary situations…things that are not so far-fetched that we can’t relate to them, but are still out of most peoples’ reach: champion child spellers, kids playing Black Sabbath on the guitar in the context of “school”. They use the same cinematic tricks as mainstream Hollywood films to engage the audience, build our trust and empathy for the characters, introduce a crisis (which gets us rooting for the good guys) and then resolving it, in a tidy package of 90 minutes.

Everyone knows that “real life” doesn’t work that way, so why do we expect that documentaries (or for that matter, reality television) can capture “real life”? The timeframe and format of non-experimental mainstream film cannot accommodate the complexities, the boredom, and the qualities of time/events passing that our daily lives contain.

The value of a documentary is that it can be a glimpse, a window into a larger world that the viewer doesn’t have access to. It can be an affirmation of concerns, fears, the hopes of its audience. But it can’t be a portrayal of an unmediated or “pure” reality, even if that is what we want…

eyes on the prize

It's almost embarassing that I've never come across this series before in my education, or life in general. It's obviously an incredible project to achieve in general - in scope, scale, and execution. It turns out that a friend of mine had the series checked out from the Temple library, she was watching it for the sake of watching it, and had been making her way through the whole series. She handed it off to me and said, "Here, this is amazing and emotinally devistating - I've been crying my way through a dvd every night." Her reaction to the series definitely set my expectations on a particular slant, and I found I had to work very hard to look at the work in several ways. First, I had to watch simply as a human, and let the horrific history of our country methodically reveal itself, and just sit with it. I found within that I was watching the film as a white person, who obviously grew up in a de-segregated society that is technically post civil-rights, and while the history, subject matter, and some of the footage is certainly a part of my education, history, and "image bank" it's emotionally and intellectually compelling to watch so thorough and extensive a document and to put it in a context today of race relations in the US, in this city, in this part of the city, in this school, and at this time, is very powerful. It was inspiring to see a work that focused on the agency and effort of people involved in the civil rights movement that are not famous and who lived their lives, or moments of their lives, with such necessity and conviction. That said, I had a hard time focusing on the parts of me that are supposed to be in film class, and analyzing this as a part of a documentary fictions class. What are the fictions, are there any? Does this film breach the actual with the fiction? Are there moments when it approaches propaganda? Are there emotionally manipulative devices at work in the music, narration? Does it matter? It's almost too close to home to look objectively, and it's one of few instances in this class where I didn't have a negative association with any of the devices at work.

the house on 92nd street

I too read this film as a propaganda film - it promotes both gender-appropriate behavior (and morals) and a pro-America mentality. The things that really tipped the film into propaganda for me were the music and the scripting/narrator. I've found in a few films this semester (Primary comes to mind as one) that the music - what kind and when - is very influential. The opening scene of House on 92nd street uses an instrumental version of "My Country tis of Thee" as the camera moves from a long shot of the White House to closing in on the FBI building which unmistakably is meant to stir a patriotic sentiment. The narrator is Reed Hadley, who at the time had a very recognizable voice and narrated government training films, etc. His voice was recognizable as informed and authoritive and in house on 92nd that voice is definitely all-knowing, all-seeing, and leaves little room anywhere for interpretation, or misinterpretation, of the images we are seeing. The film promotes an ethice sameness/whiteness - as we tour the FBI building there is no discernable ethnic or racial variety among any of the employees, whereas the enemy, the Germans and those Americans who help them have qualities, such as an accent, a swagger, a style of dress, the puts them outside of the white anglo-saxon protestant mold we see at the FBI. The women at the FBI, and by extension in American, are relegated to secretarial roles, where they catalog and manage volumes of information exclusively generated by the male FBI employees. The women have no agency or imperative in the information, no personal relationship to it - and while managing and cataloging this information is an important and necessary role, it doesn't have to, in it's nature, be done by women alone - and there is no reason why these women could not also be scientists or investigators, and no reason why men could not work filing and managing the data - no reason, or course, besides sexism. I kept thinking about "Rosie the Riveter" during these scenes of women working at the FBI - about the fact that during world war II the government pushed for women to leave their roles of working in the home and recruited them to work in factories and in other roles normaly occupied by men (thus the "we can do it" Rosie the Riveter campaign) and alot of women enjoyed this opportunity to work outside of the home, have their own income, and to build a new skill set. When the war was over, however, the government urged women to leave these jobs and return to being housewives or secretaries or other jobs that were considered "women's work". I wonder if any of this was in the atmosphere during the making of this film.

The Nichols Reading

Although the style of writing is less conversational than others, Nichols' insight into the world of documentary is very interesting. Prior to this class (and this reading in particular), I wasn't aware of the nomenclature and sub-classes that exist within the field, much less what separates each category.

I really appreciated his explanation of "reflexivity" as a way to understand documentaries.

That said, I feel that the language was an unnecessary barrier when trying to explain an already complex genre. Some of the words even seemed made-up (talismanic).

Regardless, it provided new terms to help dissect what we've seen in class, and distinguish the real from the fake. Even if his vocabulary falls in the gray.

Symbiopsychotaxiplasm

This film is reflexive in every tense of the term. Not only is it a film about making a film and all the pitfalls associated, but it is also a study in viewer's understanding.

As the story - or the lack of which - unfolded, I found myself increasing attached to these characters. It was as if, despite the fact that the scene took place in the 60's, that they were talking about any of my film classes and projects. By keeping things very open and non-specific, the film crew of Symbiopsychotaxiplasm were addressing life as a whole.

Primary

I watched Primary several times outside of class, and each time I found myself asking if I really thought the film was balanced, were the editing choices meant to sway the view one way or the other? It seems clear throughout the film that Kennedy is much more comfortable in front of the camera and more photogenic and even charismatic than Humphrey. I wonder if this fact alone might sway both a cameraperson and an editor to edit in your favor whether they realize it or not? With minimal narration, the natural trajectory of the narrative is told almost exclusively through visuals. It was Drew's intention to produce a balanced and fair picture of the primary and upon first watch I didn't think he accomplished this. It seemed that Kennedy continually came out looking better and Humphrey looked rather boring, to such a degree I wondered if the film hadn't been made to do so. Then, after repeated viewings, my opinion started to sway. I think it's actually the overall passage of time that changed the perspective with which the footage is viewed. Looking at Primary now seems more like viewing for the sake of investigating the life of a person who everyone thought/hoped would change the world and as he was, he was murdered for it. I found myself almost impulsively drawn to examine Kennedy more closely, to see footage of this legend that I hadn't seen before really distracted me from a more careful read of the film. After roughly estimating screen time, it seems rather equal and the moments where Humphrey is almost aggressively seeking people to talk to, where his own travelmates are dozing while he's talking, and where there are not many people at his appearances - well, it's clear that he owns those moments, undeniably. The camera is just recording what happened. The effect though, is that in the end I am surprised the race was not a complete and total landslide in Kennedy's favor. It's worth noting, though, that Drew went on to make more films about the Kennedys and while there wouldnt be much of a film to make about HUmphrey, it's just interesting to me that Drew continued to have a relationship with the Kennedy's.

Waiting For Guffman

Waiting for Guffman is interesting because Guest created a sense of reality while smudging the truth enough to cause soe giggles. It wasn't a doc. fiction in the classic sense since it's aim was to capture real desires versus actual events---or events that could even bbe actual. Behind all the laughs, were effective devices like one-on-one interviews, interestig use of sound, and dead plot time to signify real life. there was no neat story round-up, or even a clearly good/bad guy. each person acted out their role to show one particular side of a psyche.