May 7, 2007
Good Night and Good Luck
The Battle of San Pietro / December 7th
Phony Definitions
steve neale, triumph of the will
The television genre book
Bill Nicoles: Modes of Representation
Jonathan Rosenbaum
Hail Primary
Leacock uncontrolled cinema
No Lies
Documentary Style in Citizen Kane
After the opening scene in which Charles Foster Kane utters his final word and passes away, the film transitions to the “News on the March” newsreel. The choice to incorporate the documentary style into Citizen Kane was most likely because Welles felt it was the best way to create the illusion that this man was real. Handheld shots were utilized and supposedly some of the negatives were run across the editing room floor to add scratches and dust to make it appear like it has been projected so many times. Combined with the “voice of god” narration, this segment of the film attempts to show the viewer the true story of the character’s successes and failures in life. It also sets up an objective view of who Kane was, and these facts will either be supported or contradicted as the film goes on and the reporter interviews those close to Kane.
When Orson Welles conceptualized the “News on the March” segment, he was just continuing what he started with his War of the Worlds radio broadcast, which was trying to convince the audience into believing something is real, making the film more enjoyable.
Drama/Documentary
Movies are powerful, and can have the power to re-energize or even re-write popular versions of history (as Linda Williams writes in “Mirrors Without Memories”). If that is true (and I do agree with her) then the question of historical authenticity or of disclosure from the filmmakers becomes quite interesting.
Responsibility and accountability in filmmaking (and in any art in general, really) are constant yet shifting issues. As a maker of art, should you contextualize your work for your audience? (maybe…) As a consumer/critic of art, should you consider its production and historical accuracy? (probably…) I think that the responsibility for making connections beyond the work out into the rest of the world (art world, film world, or whole world) is up to the viewer/consumer, and not the artist. As a maker of media, you should be aware of your context, histories and genres and try to anticipate and understand the implications of your work. What you choose to do about these things is clearly a more personal, singular decision, but reflexive awareness adds clarity, and the ability to discuss and define those choices can only aid in your own understanding of your work.
Having said that, I think that the audience also has a responsibility to be active, and more active than we are typically are asked to be in our consumption of films, art etc., If we are accountable to ourselves and to each other, and discuss the film/art, there is the possibility of understanding something broader or more applicable, its ramifications in our lives, or seeing something in a new way. Through dialogue, any authenticity, history, or lack thereof can be challenged, allowing another story/reality to emerge.
Stiry/Discourse
A Note On Two Kinds Of Voyeurism
The author describes a balance of physical absence and presence in the cinema: when the actors are acting, the audience is not there, and when the audience is watching, the actors are gone, leaving their performances captured on film. They position this relationship as typical of cinema, and parallel it with the historical rise in the importance of the private individual vs. the community, by suggesting that the spectator doesn’t need to be seen while watching nor does the person being watched need to see the “see-er”. Both understand their specific roles, though there is not an activity that is shared between them, and a dialogue or interaction is impossible.
I think that this distancing of the subject (active, watcher) from the object (passive, actor) in this equation facilitates some of the “magic” of movies. It, along with the specific characteristics of film as a medium, allows the construction of a more “believable” world, a faraway fantasy world, where the viewer can see the actor and watch their every (calculated, edited, scripted) move with no real physical consequence, though they still engage emotionally with the story. Different from plays or live musical performances, movies can allow for a closer-than-normal/hyper real understanding of a situation or story, by specifying a frame for the viewer. Using cinematography, musical scores, sound editing, and special effects, movies have a one-way communication out of the screen and into the eyes/ears of the audience. The actors never hear the clapping at the end of the screening (which I always think is an odd thing to witness and points to a sort of collective audience experience) – and yet they never fail to be motivated to perform.
Documentary Contradictions
Don’t we ignore this contradiction in all movies? Do we want the same things from documentaries as we want from fictional films: sympathetic characters, compelling crisis, understandable and complete resolution? Because documentaries are based in “reality”, we expect a portrayal that is unencumbered by cinematic/narrative structures. The impossibility of this all-seeing camera or unbiased portrayal is suggested by Winston, and has easy proofs. It seems we crave, or are trained, or almost expect fictional devices anyway – we will put the pieces together and construct a narrative whether we are given one or not.
Popular, contemporary documentaries like Spellbound or Rock School show “real people” in “real” but somewhat extraordinary situations…things that are not so far-fetched that we can’t relate to them, but are still out of most peoples’ reach: champion child spellers, kids playing Black Sabbath on the guitar in the context of “school”. They use the same cinematic tricks as mainstream Hollywood films to engage the audience, build our trust and empathy for the characters, introduce a crisis (which gets us rooting for the good guys) and then resolving it, in a tidy package of 90 minutes.
Everyone knows that “real life” doesn’t work that way, so why do we expect that documentaries (or for that matter, reality television) can capture “real life”? The timeframe and format of non-experimental mainstream film cannot accommodate the complexities, the boredom, and the qualities of time/events passing that our daily lives contain.
The value of a documentary is that it can be a glimpse, a window into a larger world that the viewer doesn’t have access to. It can be an affirmation of concerns, fears, the hopes of its audience. But it can’t be a portrayal of an unmediated or “pure” reality, even if that is what we want…
eyes on the prize
the house on 92nd street
The Nichols Reading
I really appreciated his explanation of "reflexivity" as a way to understand documentaries.
That said, I feel that the language was an unnecessary barrier when trying to explain an already complex genre. Some of the words even seemed made-up (talismanic).
Regardless, it provided new terms to help dissect what we've seen in class, and distinguish the real from the fake. Even if his vocabulary falls in the gray.
Symbiopsychotaxiplasm
As the story - or the lack of which - unfolded, I found myself increasing attached to these characters. It was as if, despite the fact that the scene took place in the 60's, that they were talking about any of my film classes and projects. By keeping things very open and non-specific, the film crew of Symbiopsychotaxiplasm were addressing life as a whole.