April 26, 2007

Purpose of War Games

On the surface, Peter Watkin's Culloden and War Games seem similar. They are both sponsored by BBC and both try to enlighten the viewers on history/future. However, just by viewing, War Games has a severely different tone that is not meant to educate but to enlighten. In Culloden, there were actual characters recreating the war scenes of Battle of Culloden. The film was shot as if it was taken from a news clip of the Vietnam war. War Games has a much more narrative feel. The use of titles cards within the film directs the viewer into the director's more obvious message; we have gone too far. Culloden just used interviews in the film. In War Games, unlike Culloden, the words spoken are framed by phrases such as "based on" to give a sense of authority. Watkins was using War Games to urge the public that we have damaged humanity twice and there will inevitably be a third time. There was no such urgency within Culloden. Though it had a moral message, it remained in the psudeo-reality. War Games so obviously played on the parody of documentary that the content was taken to a level beyond entertainment. No wonder why BBC decided not to air such a political film.

2 comments:

Harrison Prescott said...

War Games' style of documentary had nothing to do with the outcome of its release. I think bbc didn't air it because it was so depressing and negative, and not to mention scary. It could have been a story shot in narrative style and it would have had the same affect. I agree with everything else though.

Something said...

I agree that War Game had a much more narrative style. Which left me a little confused as to what it was supposed to be. At times the film tried to be a documentary and the camera was in the action almost as another character that everyone was aware of and it gave the viewer limited information based on what was safe to capture on film during a nuclear attack. But then the camera would take on this omniscient and invisible tone, giving the viewer unattainable footage and information if it had been an actual attack.